Governing cities reflexively—The biocultural diversity concept as an alternative to ecosystem services

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2016.03.003Get rights and content
Under a Creative Commons license
open access

Highlights

  • Biocultural Diversity (BCD) renders other policy-options than the Ecosystem Services (ES) concept.

  • ES assumes a one-directional human-nature relationship and is directed towards an economic logic.

  • BCD needs to be added to the conceptual repertoire of researchers and policy-makers.

  • BCD sets up for a reflexive transdisciplinary research recognising the value-orientations of all stakeholders.

  • Reflexive governance steers towards creating spaces for contestation.

Abstract

With the aim to embed ecology more forcefully into decision-making, the concept of Ecosystems Services (ES) has gained significant ground among policy-makers and researchers. The increasing recognition of the importance of urban green areas for the quality of life in growing cities has led proponents of ES approaches to argue for an uptake of the approach in urban environmental decision-making. However, the ES approach has been criticized for standing too much at a distance from local communities and their day-to-day practices and for insufficiently taking into account the potential trade-offs between different qualities or preferences. In this paper we argue that other concepts, doing other work, need to be added to the debate about futures of urban governance and research. Biocultural diversity is suggested as one such alternative concept. By its emphasis on diversity, biocultural diversity can account for the many ways in which people live with green areas in the urban landscape, acknowledges the different knowledges this involves, and can reveal conflicts and ambivalence that may be at stake. This sets up for a reflexive, transdisciplinary research process that questions and contextualizes knowledge and worldviews including those of researchers. A reflexive, transdisciplinary research, then, is a productive catalyst for forms of reflexive urban governance that recognise and respond to this diversity and provide platforms for contestation.

Keywords

Biocultural diversity
Transdisciplinarity
Reflexive governance
Ecosystem services
Urban planning

Cited by (0)