Figures
Abstract
In wheat straw based composting, enabling growth of Agaricus bisporus mushrooms, it is unknown to which extent the carbohydrate-lignin matrix changes and how much is metabolized. In this paper we report yields and remaining structures of the major components. During the Phase II of composting 50% of both xylan and cellulose were metabolized by microbial activity, while lignin structures were unaltered. During A. bisporus’ mycelium growth (Phase III) carbohydrates were only slightly consumed and xylan was found to be partially degraded. At the same time, lignin was metabolized for 45% based on pyrolysis GC/MS. Remaining lignin was found to be modified by an increase in the ratio of syringyl (S) to guaiacyl (G) units from 0.5 to 0.7 during mycelium growth, while fewer decorations on the phenolic skeleton of both S and G units remained.
Citation: Jurak E, Punt AM, Arts W, Kabel MA, Gruppen H (2015) Fate of Carbohydrates and Lignin during Composting and Mycelium Growth of Agaricus bisporus on Wheat Straw Based Compost. PLoS ONE 10(10): e0138909. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0138909
Editor: Kristiina Hildén, University Of Helsinki, FINLAND
Received: May 8, 2015; Accepted: September 6, 2015; Published: October 5, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Jurak et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: The work described in this manuscript was performed at the Laboratory of Food Chemistry, Wageningen University, The Netherlands. EJ, WA, MK and GH were financially supported by the Technology Foundation STW (grant number 11108), applied science division of NWO and the technology programme of the Ministry of Economic Affairs (The Netherlands) and by Walkro International B.V., Sylvan Inc. and DSM Food Specialities. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Wim Arts is employed by C4C Grondstoffen B.V. C4C Grondstoffen B.V. provided support in the form of salary for author WA, but did not have any additional role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. The specific role of this author is articulated in the ‘author contributions’ section.
Competing interests: EJ, WA, MK and GH were partly supported financially by CNC Grondstoffen B.V., Walkro International B.V., Sylvan Inc. and DSM Food Specialities. Wim Arts is employed by C4C Grondstoffen B.V. There are no patents, products in development or marketed products to declare. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials, as detailed online in the guide for authors.
Highlights:
- 50% of xylan and cellulose are metabolized in composting.
- During A. bisporus’ mycelium growth 45% of lignin was metabolized.
- S:G ratio of remaining lignin increases from 0.5 to 0.7 during mycelium growth.
- Part of the guaiacyl units of lignin become water soluble during mycelium growth.
Introduction
In the conventional European process, compost for mushroom growth is produced from a basic mixture (BM) of straw bedded horse manure, wheat straw, poultry manure and gypsum [1]. The BM composition and duration of composting phases can differ in different parts of the world, but compost always serves as carbon and nitrogen source for Agaricus bisporus’ mushroom growth.
The main ingredient in the European compost, wheat straw, contains about 57% (w/w) of carbohydrates, mostly cellulose (44 mol%) and xylan (46 mol%), and 27% (w/w) of lignin [2]. Cellulose is a non-branched polymer of β-1,4-linked glucosyl units. Xylan in grasses, like wheat straw, is composed of a 1,4-linked β-D-xylopyranosyl-backbone with arabinosyl, O-acetyl and (4-O-methyl-) glucuronic acid side chains [3]. However, the exact amounts and distribution of all substituents on wheat straw xylan is not reported. Lignin is composed of three main monolignols: p-hydroxyphenyl (H), guaiacyl (G) and syringyl (S) phenylpropanoid units. In wheat straw lignin all three units are present (H:G:S ratio of 6:64:30; [4]). Cellulose, xylan and lignin form together a complex, hard to degrade, network. In grasses, like wheat straw, xylan can adsorb to cellulose, but also be oxidatively cross-linked with other xylan molecules and with lignin via hydroxycinnamic acid residues [5]. Composting aims at opening up such a complex to facilitate release of monosaccharides, which serve as carbon source during A. bisporus’ mushroom growth [2]. As such, composting has a similar goal as many other pre-treatments of lignocellulosic plant biomass aiming at an improved enzymatic release of fermentable monosaccharides to produce biofuels and chemicals from. Therefore, insights in the reactions occurring could be of use for other pre-treated plant materials.
The industrial production of compost is carried out in closed tunnels and involves three phases, described in detail elsewhere [2]. In brief, meso- and thermophilic microbiota decompose BM (Phase I (PI)), causing a rise in temperature to 80°C and release of ammonia. In the next phase (PII), microorganisms, in particular actinomycetes and fungi, consume at a maximum of 60°C about 40% of the ammonia present, while the other part disappears in the air [6]. As a result of two composting phases, compost has become accessible and specific for A. bisporus mycelium growth in the third phase at temperatures around 24°C for 16 days (PIII–16). In PIII, the A. bisporus mycelium is known to consume (part of) the microbiota present [7]. For optimal growth the A. bisporus mycelium needs also to degrade and consume the carbohydrates and, possibly, lignin present [1, 2]. PIII–16 compost is considered mature and by adding a casing layer on top of this compost the fruiting body formation starts [6].
Composting is an accelerated version of natural decomposition of lignocellulose by the microorganisms present [8]. The activity of these microorganisms and growth of A. bisporus chemically alters the compost [1, 2]. Quantification of remaining components, like xylan, cellulose, lignin and protein, however, has not been reported. So far, mainly qualitative changes in compost composition have been reported, with a focus on a decrease in carbohydrate and protein as based on total dry matter [1, 2, 9]. Lignin degradation has been mentioned, but only indirect evidence was shown, either by investigating whether A. bisporus can grow on radioactive labelled 14C lignin or by determining the presence of laccase-activity and manganese peroxidase. The latter is hypothesized to be linked to lignin degradation during mycelium growth [10, 11]. Although important, these results lack the possibility to determine absolute quantities of carbohydrates, lignin and protein metabolized.
In our research, in a tunnel-experiment at industrial scale, a mass balance was conducted for dry matter as well as for proteins, cellulose, xylan, lignin and ash. In addition, the structural changes of xylan and lignin were studied. Mapping the amounts and structures of the main components available for mushroom growth is essential for improving the process. Generally, our study contributes to the understanding how wheat straw compost is degraded.
Materials and Methods
Composting process
At the composting company CNC-C4C (Milsbeek, The Netherlands) basic mixture (BM) was obtained by mixing on a wet basis, 63% w/w of fresh horse manure, 2% w/w of gypsum, 1% w/w of ammonium sulphate solution (20% w/v (NH4)2SO4 in water), 17% w/w of filtered percolate water, 11% w/w of chicken manure, 4% w/w straw and 2% w/w of water. Fresh horse manure and wheat straw were collected in October 2013 and the experiment was carried out in October and November 2013. For this experiment, one tunnel was assigned for compost production from which all samples were taken from. The composting phases are described elsewhere [2]. In addition to the previously described information, it should be mentioned that the PI phase lasted for 5 days, and reached 80°C under formation of ammonia, after which PI compost was obtained. To PI compost 10 g kg−1 of PII compost was added to introduce viable microflora necessary for the conditioning phase. The duration of PII was also 5 days. To PII compost 4.5 g kg−1 of rye-based spawn was added and inoculated for 16 days after which PIII–16 mycelium grown compost was obtained.
Samples
All samples were taken from the same original BM (same timeline). The first tunnel (35 x 4 x 4 meter) was filled with 200 tons of BM. Of this BM 100 kg was kept apart and divided into 3 batches (A, B, C) of about 33 kg. Each batch was handled separately and placed in onion mesh bags in the same tunnel (Fig 1). Per batch two bags (biological duplicates) were prepared and weighed (min 15 kg), labelled (e.g. A–1 and A–2) and placed over the length of the tunnel, about 30 cm below the surface of BM compost. After phase PI, both bags from the corresponding batch were weighed and afterwards thoroughly mixed, and one sample (min 1 kg) was taken from each batch (A, B and C). After sampling, the material was again mixed and divided over two bags and placed in the tunnel for phase PII (35 x 4 x 3.62 meter). Total compost in PII tunnel was 200 tons. The same procedure was followed for phase PIII (tunnel 35 x 4 x 3.62 meter, total compost 144 tons). So, for each sampling step (end of each phase) three samples (biological triplicates) were obtained (min 1 kg). Throughout the complete composting process, the batches (A, B and C) were weighed at the end of each phase and all the changes (addition of water, spawn) were noted. Weight of each sample (batch) was determined after sampling and after collecting, samples were immediately frozen at -18°C. First, the dry matter content was determined for each sample (100 g, 105°C overnight). From the fresh weight of each batch the dry matter yield was determined for PI, PII and PIII–16. The dry matter yield was 91.9% of PI, of PII 77.1% and of PIII–16 69.4% (average of three batches, STDEV 1.2, 1.9 and 1.9, respectively). Dried samples were milled (<1 mm) using an MM 2000 mill (Retsch, Haan, Germany) prior to further analysis. Samples were analyzed for their protein, carbohydrate, ash and lignin contents for each sample (batch). Contents of all analyzed components was summed up and compared to the dry matter content of corresponding sample and the recovery was found to be >95%. In addition, the carbohydrate and lignin composition was analyzed.
Preparation of water un-extractable solids (WUS)
For batch A, freeze dried, milled samples (5 g) of BM, PI, PII and PIII–16 was suspended in water (175 mL) and boiled at 100°C for 5 min. Next, the suspension was stirred for 16 h at 21°C. The supernatant was removed after centrifugation (10 000 x g, 30 min, 20°C) and the residue was washed twice with water (60 mL and 75 mL). The final residues were freeze dried and collected as water un-extractable solids (e.g. PI-WUS). Samples were analyzed for yield, protein and dry matter contents.
Analytical techniques and methods
Carbohydrate content and composition.
The neutral carbohydrate and uronic acid content and composition was determined in duplicate, as described by Jurak et al. [2].
Nitrogen and protein content.
Samples (7–10 mg) were analyzed for nitrogen content in duplicate using the combustion (DUMAS) method on a Flash EA 1112 Nitrogen Analyzer (Thermo Scientific, Sunnyvale, CA, USA). Methionine (Acros Organics, Geel, Belgium) was used as a standard. Nitrogen content in the water soluble extract was calculated by difference. Nitrogen to protein conversion factor of 6.25 was used [12]. For PIII–16, due to the presence of A. bisporus mycelium in compost, protein was not specified (n.s. Table 1).
BM: basic mixture; PI: compost after Phase I; PII: compost after Phase II; PIII–16: compost after 16 days of mycelium growth for batch A.
Ash content.
Freeze dried samples (1 g) or lignin residues (200–400 mg; see 2.4.4.) were dried in the oven overnight (105°C) and weighed, then put at 575°C for 5 h. Next, samples were weighed and difference between the mass at 105°C and 575°C was taken as ash content. Additionally, samples were burned at 575°C for 16 h more and afterwards weighed. No difference in mass was observed between residue after 5 h and 21 h.
Klason lignin residue and acid soluble lignin (ASL).
To each sample of 1 g (dry matter) 10 mL of 72% w/w H2SO4 was added and samples were hydrolyzed for 1h at 30°C. Next, 100 mL of distilled water was added to each sample and samples were put in a boiling water bath for 3h and shaken every half hour. Next, the suspensions were filtered over G4 glass filters. The filtrate was measured for acid soluble lignin (ASL) spectrophotometrically at 205 nm. ASL was calculated according to the formula: ASL = (A * B * C)/(D * E), with A = absorption relative to 1M H2SO4, B = dilution factor, C = filtrate volume, D = extinction coefficient for lignin (110 g L−1 cm−1), and E = weight of substrate (g). The residual part was washed until it was free of acid (determined by using pH paper) and dried overnight at 105°C. The final residues were corrected for ash and considered as a measure for the acid insoluble lignin (Klason) content after ash-correction. To this end, acid insoluble lignin was burned for ash. Total lignin was defined as a sum of Klason lignin residue, corrected for ash, and acid soluble lignin. For wheat straw, Klason lignin content corrected for ash was 27% (w/w) and acid soluble lignin content was 1.9% (w/w) based on dry matter.
Lignin analysis by analytical pyrolysis-GC-MS (Py-GC/MS).
Pyrolysis was performed with a 2020 microfurnace pyrolyzer (Frontier Laboratories, New Ulm, MN, USA) equipped with an AS-1020E Autoshot. Components were identified by GC-MS using a Trace GC equipped with a DB–1701 fused-silica capillary column (30 m x 0.25 mm i.d. 0.25 μm film thickness) coupled to a DSQ-II (EI at 70 eV) (both Thermo Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA). The pyrolysis was performed at 500°C for 1 min. Helium was the carrier gas (1 mL min−1). Samples (60–70 μg) were pyrolyzed and each measurement was performed at least in triplicate. Initial oven temperature was 70°C (2 min hold) and it increased to 230°C with a rate of 5°C min−1, to 240°C by 2.5°C min−1 and finally to 270°C min−1 by 2.5°C min−1. Pure compounds were used as standards (Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA; Brunshwig Chemie B.V., Amsterdam, The Netherlands and Fisher Scientific, Landsmeer, The Netherlands) and peak molar area was calculated as defined by del Rio [13]. For wheat straw a cut-off of 1% molar area for single S (syringyl-like lignin structures) and G (guaiacyl-like lignin structures) compounds was applied and only the fate of remaining compounds (>1% molar area) was analyzed for compost samples. Compounds with a molar area >1% in wheat straw are specified in Fig 2. For WUS, the fate of the same S and G compounds as in original compost was compared. Remaining S and G compounds were annotated as Rest S* and Rest G*. The same cut-off level was applied for phenolic furanose/pyranose (F/P) and unknown compounds based on total area of these compounds. F/ P compounds with a molar area >1% are annotated in S1 Table. The remaining compounds are specified in S2 Table. Amdis software (version 2.71, NIST, USA) was used for identification and deconvolution of peaks. For deconvolution the following parameters were set: adjacent peak subtraction = one, resolution = medium, sensitivity = high and shape requirements = low. For identification a target compound library (based on referents standards) was built. Referents standards were measured in order to obtain retention time (RT) information and mass spectra (Fig 2, S1 Table and S2 Table). Compounds identified based on referents standards were, first, selected based on RT (± 1.0 min; or ± 0.1 min for isomers). If RT was within the selected window an annotation was given if reversed search (RS) value was higher than 80%. Finally, for all WS compounds, also the ones identified based on Ralph and Hatfield [14], spectra were checked manually. Total annotated area of S- and G- lignin units in wheat straw was ±80%.
aInterpretation based on pure compounds. bInterpretation based on Ralph and Hatfield (1991), reverse search of compound in compost or WUS versus compound in wheat straw: 34S>99%, 42S>97%, 49S>99%. RS = reverse search
Estimation of lignin quantities with analytical Py-GC/MS.
To estimate absolute amounts of lignin in the samples, the areas of Py-GC/MS pyrograms were assumed to indicate amounts of lignin units present. As a base, the total lignin content (sum of Klason lignin (26.5% w/w) and ASL (1.9% w/w)) of wheat straw was correlated with the area under the Py-GC/MS pyrograms of wheat straw. Molar areas of S- and G-units annotated in Fig 2 and S2 Table were summed up as total molar area. For wheat straw and compost samples about 85% of dry matter was pyrolyzed in the Py-GC/MS, based on gravimetric analysis prior and after the pyrolysis. As the same amount of sample was weighed and pyrolyzed for wheat straw and compost samples it was assumed that correlation between wheat straw and compost lignin could be made. Also, in compost samples, lignin originates only from wheat straw. The correlation between total molar area of S and G with the w/w % of total lignin in wheat straw, was used to calculate the w/w % of lignin in compost samples based on the molar Py-GC/MS areas of the compost samples analysed. Lastly, obtained values for w/w % of lignin based on dry matter in compost samples was used to calculate the mass balance of lignin in PI, PII and PIII–16.
Results and Discussion
Dry matter, organic matter, carbohydrate and protein mass balance during composting and mycelium growth phases
The contents based on dry matter of carbohydrates, ash, Klason lignin residue (- ash) and nitrogen were analyzed for all three batches (A, B and C) are presented on a dry matter basis in Table 2. Previously, the composition of compost was reported for compost samples from BM, PI, PII and PIII–16 [2]. In that research, samples were obtained by mixing multiple compost samples from different tunnels with the aim to study the remaining carbohydrate structures, and a mass balance could not be performed. However, in order to fully understand the changes in the compost, a mass balance for dry matter as well as for proteins, cellulose, xylan, lignin and ash and, therefore, samples from the same timeline is needed. From Table 2, batch C was found to be an outlier with respect to carbohydrate content and dry matter content of Phase I (PI). Namely, in 1000 kg of basic mixture (BM), based on the carbohydrate content, 424 kg of carbohydrates were present compared to 440 kg in PI, for batch C. While 439 kg in BM and 412 kg in PI and 449 kg in BM and 420 kg in PI of carbohydrates, were calculated for batch A and B, respectively. So, only for batch C this would, impossibly, indicate a gain in carbohydrates in PI. Its carbohydrate content was analyzed at least 3 times indicating that this outlier was not due to an analytical error. Considering the correct values of PII and PIII–16, the error appeared to have occurred in the sampling after PI. Hence, after carbohydrate and ash analysis, batch C was excluded from further analysis. Nevertheless, to our opinion the values obtained for batch A and B give representative data for the mass balance, also, because the numbers obtained are very close to the yearly average mass balance values of CNC-C4C (personal communication with CNC-C4C).
The carbohydrate contents (based on dry matter) of batch A and B was found to be, on average, 44% w/w for BM, 46% w/w for PI, 26% w/w for Phase II (PII) and 26% for PIII–16. Ash content was found to be 21%, 22%, 29% and 30% for BM, PI, PII and PIII–16, respectively (w/w based on dry matter). Total nitrogen content was 1.3%, 1.4%, 2.1% and 2.2% for BM, PI, PII and PIII–16, respectively and water insoluble nitrogen content was found to be 0.8%, 0.8%, 1.6% and 2.1% for BM, PI, PII and PIII–16, respectively (w/w based on dry matter). Lastly, Klason lignin contents, corrected for ash, were 21%, 22%, 23% and 21% for BM, PI, PII and PIII–16, respectively (w/w based on dry matter).
Next, for batch A the mass balance concerning ash, protein, carbohydrates and lignin during composting and mycelium growth is presented (Table 1) based on a starting amount of 1000 kg dry matter BM. The totals of all analyzed components covered 95% w/w or more of the total amount of dry matter, indicating the completeness of the analyses performed. Compared to BM, a decrease of 8% w/w of dry matter was analyzed for PI, 23% w/w for PII and 31% w/w for PIII–16.
Overall, some variations in the absolute amounts of ash was observed (Table 1). Previously, variations in the amount of inorganic materials during composting have been reported [1]. Ash present mainly originated from sand and stones found in the commercial compost solids. Possibly, these are introduced together with recycled process-water, and therefore present in various amounts in the different samples (personal communication CNC-C4C). Such ash-recycles may also contribute to the higher decrease in organic matter (OM) compared with DM (Table 1).
Total nitrogen remained rather similar in the compost during composting and mycelium growth. Given the low nitrogen values (% w/w, Table 2), comparison of absolute nitrogen amounts should be performed with caution. Given this, a tendency in increase of water insoluble nitrogen might be observed in PII compost compared to PI compost. During PI rise in temperature to 80°C [2] and formation of ammonia was observed (personal communication CNC-C4C) indicating microbial growth of meso- and thermophilic microbiota [6], however, no big differences in carbohydrate and lignin content were observed (Table 2). In contrast to this, a tendency in increase in the amount of total nitrogen and protein in PII (mass balance, Table 1) could be interpreted. During PII a decrease in the organic matter (18% w/w) and carbohydrates (±50% w/w for both xylan and cellulose present (Fig 3)) was observed. During this phase up to 40% of ammonia is reported to be removed by microbiota, actinomycetes and fungi, present [6] with temperatures around 50°C [2] and higher humidity compared to PI (Table 1). With caution it could be proposed that one of the possible explanations for this observation is the growth of nitrogen-fixating and other viable microbiota introduced into compost at the beginning of PII [15, 16].
aCalculation was performed based on 1000 kg of DM using values presented in Tables 1 and 4.
In PIII–16 (Table 1) temperatures are maintained around 25°C [2] and humidity is higher (±8%) compared to PII. The amount of protein in PIII–16 increased further, mainly seen in the increase in water insoluble nitrogen, and the amount of carbohydrates decreased slightly both in xylan and cellulose (Fig 3), most likely as a result of the observed mycelium growth in this phase [17, 18]. It should be noted that due to the formation of mycelium dry matter, partly built from glucan, the decrease in compost-glucan (cellulose; Fig 3) derived from the starting material is underestimated. Namely, in our analysis, total glucan was analyzed, regardless whether it originated from plant or microbial origin. Finally, mannitol was analyzed to be present in PIII–16 compost, which is a known soluble carbohydrate in the mycelium of A. bisporus [19].
Overall, the molar composition of the compost carbohydrates in BM, PI, PII and PIII–16 (Table 3) remained rather similar and is in line with previously reported data [2]. However, a decrease in xylosyl residues could be observed in PIII–16 compared to PII. In all phases, the main carbohydrate constituents were xylosyl (28–35 mol%) and glucosyl (52–56 mol%) residues, which is in agreement with previously published data [2]. Recently, it was shown that during PIII compost xylan is partly degraded, thereby, making it more water soluble [2] which is expected to provide more easily accessible carbohydrates during fruiting of A. bisporus. In the present study, no division between water soluble and water insoluble glucans and xylan was performed.
BM: basic mixture; PI: compost after Phase I; PII: compost after Phase II; PIII–16: compost after 16 days of mycelium growth.
Lignin mass balance during composting and mycelium growth phases
First, the Klason lignin analysis was applied to a lab-cultivated A. bisporus mycelium sample, which allowed us to observe the fate of mycelium in this analysis. It was shown that more than 50% of the mycelium dry matter, was collected as ‘Klason lignin’. This indicated that the Klason lignin analysis in samples containing substantial amounts of mycelium, like in PIII–16, would give an overestimation of the lignin present as mushroom mycelium would be analyzed as “lignin” by this method. Also, denatured proteins are known to remain in the Klason lignin residues [1]. Nevertheless, Klason lignin residues were analyzed for batch A (Table 1), allowing comparison with the scarce previously reported data on compost composition [1]. For PI and PII values obtained for Klason lignin corrected for ash were in line with values reported by Iiyama et al. [1].
Lignin structure and content was also analyzed as single monolignol units by analytical Py-GC/MS. Based on the correlation between the wheat straw Klason lignin content, and the area of annotated S- and G-units in the wheat straw pyrogram obtained, from the pyrogram-areas of the compost samples (in triplicate) the lignin yield in these samples was calculated, based on 1000 kg BM dry matter (Table 4). In general, the amount of pyrogram based lignin remained rather similar during composting (PI and PII). In contrast, a decrease of 45% w/w in the amount of lignin, based on pyrolysis, was observed after 16 days of mycelium growth. The overall difference in kg between BM and PIII–16 is more pronounced by the GC/MS analysis than by the classical Klason lignin analysis. This also accounts for the decrease in dry matter during the PIII phase. In our opinion, the Py-GC/MS data are more representative for the lignin amounts present than the Klason lignin residue analysis, because with the former technique only lignin derived pyrolysis units were taken into account in the quantification in mycelium grown compost samples. The GC/MS analysis leads to the total lignin yield based on constituent units present after pyrolysis. Hence, this technique also provided valuable data on compositional changes during the different phases.
BM: basic mixture; PI: compost after Phase I; PII: compost after Phase II; PIII–16: compost after 16 days of mycelium growth.
Structural changes of lignin during composting and mycelium growth phase
The Py-GC/MS lignin-fingerprints of the BM, PI, PII and PIII–16 composts were annotated based on the fully annotated pyrogram of untreated wheat straw (Fig 4A). The pattern and main annotated peaks of lignin compounds for wheat straw were in line with previously reported data [4]. Due to better baseline separation and additional spectra measured from standard lignin compounds, some peaks (e.g. trans-isoeugenol, 4-methylsyringol, vanilin) were differently annotated than previously reported (Fig 2, S1 Table and S2 Table) [4].
The identities and structures of main syringyl and guaiacyl (and p-hydroxyphenyl) compounds are listed in Fig 2, S1 Table and S2 Table. PI: compost after Phase I: PII: compost after Phase II.
For BM the pattern and the ratios between peaks is quite similar to those of wheat straw, which was expected as lignin in BM-compost originates from wheat straw. Also, the pyrograms of PI and PII composts were majorly similar as the ones of BM and wheat straw. In Phase III, however, the ratios (in molar area) between some monolignol-units, mainly vinyl-guaiacol, guaiacol, vinyl-syringol and syringol, were very different between the BM and PIII–16 pyrograms (Fig 4).
In order to understand the differences observed during mycelium growth, first, the various monolignol-units present in the pyrogram of wheat straw are discussed. As previously stated, wheat straw lignin is mainly composed of S- (syringyl-like) and G- (guaiacyl-like) lignin units, and to a minor extent of H (p-hydroxyphenyl) units. Therefore, we focused on S and G lignin units.
The S:G ratios of wheat straw and different compost samples was calculated and is shown in Fig 5A. The S:G ratio in wheat straw was 0.49 (Fig 5A), which is in line with the value reported by del Rio [4], where vinyl-syringol and vinyl-guaiacol were excluded from the S:G ratio. The S:G ratio in PI and PII remained 0.51. After 16 days of mycelium growth (PIII–16), the S:G ratio changed to 0.68 (Fig 5A), indicating a modification in lignin by A. bisporus mycelium. The pyrograms obtained for compost samples as well as S:G values are found to be in line with values reported by Chen et al. [20] however, annotated peaks were not specified and the samples used were collected from different stages in the process. Therefore, these results are difficult to compare.
Rest S* and Rest G* S2 Table, BM: basic mixture; PI: compost after Phase I: PII: compost after Phase II; PIII–16: compost after 16 days of mycelium growth, A and B are biological duplicates and each sample measurement was performed in quadruplicates.
Changes in distribution of S and G lignin units were determined for S and G structures with molar area larger than 1% of total S+G molar area (Fig 2). Remaining annotated compounds are presented in S1 Table and S2 Table (see materials and methods), but not taken into account further.
Compared to PII compost, a lower proportion of substituted vinyl-syringyol and vinyl-guaiacol lignin compounds in PIII–16 compost was present in favor of the less substituted guaiacol and syringol (Figs 2 and 4). This may point at cleavage of substituents on the phenolic skeleton during PIII (Fig 5B). The observed modification of substituents is mainly observed in “vinyl- groups” leading to a relative decrease in vinyl-guaiacol and vinyl-syringol during PIII. Lignin structures analyzed by NMR in wheat straw [4] indicate that such vinyl-decorations are mainly responsible for inter-lignin linkages. Therefore, our findings suggest that A. bisporus is capable of cleaving larger lignin structures into smaller ones, and further remove the decorations leaving mainly the basic S and G phenolic skeletons of the lignin structures.
In previous research [4], vinyl-guaiacol and vinyl-syringol were excluded from the S:G ratio as during pyrolysis p-hydroxycinnamates are known to result in the same compounds as those derived from lignin. If these compounds were only part of xylan, it could lead to overestimation of lignin. However, in BM, due to high pH, no free and ester bound FA (ferulic acid) and very low amounts of pCA (p- coumaric acid) (<0.1% w/w based on dry matter) were found [2]. This indicated that in BM compost less than 0.3% (w/w based on dry matter) of ester bound FA and pCA were present. Also, the amount of vinyl-guaiacol that could be formed from FA and pCA after pyrolysis was less than 4% of the total of vinyl-guaiacol analyzed in the wheat straw pyrogram. The remaining ether-bound FA and pCA are expected to account for less than 0.5% w/w based on dry matter [21].
Composition and S:G ratio of water insoluble lignin in compost samples is presented in Fig 5 and corresponding pyrograms are presented in Fig 4. As no major compositional changes in the relative distribution of S and G lignin compounds were observed between BM and PII (Fig 5B), only for PI (PIwus) and PIII–16 (PIII-16wus) water insoluble lignin was analyzed in detail in particular for batch A. For PI the distribution of S and G compounds of PIwus-A (Fig 5A) was found to be rather similar as that of the total sample (PI-A). On the contrary, in PIII-16wus a relatively lower S:G ratio was found compared to the total sample of PIII–16 indicating that part of lignin in PIII–16 compost became more water soluble (Fig 5B).
Lignin modification in the compost by A. bisporus mycelium was previously indicated based on the degradation on 14C-labelled lignin [22] and A. bisporus was shown to produce the with lignin degradation correlated activities of manganese peroxidase and laccase in liquid cultures [23]. Recently, annotation of the A. bisporus genome indeed showed that A. bisporus contains genes encoding manganese peroxidase (MnP) and laccases [24, 25]. Regulation and expression of laccases and MnP was investigated and two genes encoding laccases and the predicted MnP gene were found to be highly expressed during mycelium growth in the compost and lower expression in the later stages of mushroom growth. In addition, the secretion of corresponding proteins indicated that laccases are secreted to a higher extent compared to MnP [24, 26]. These findings support the data presented in our research showing that A. bisporus, during the vegetative growth, was able to modify lignin structures. It is proposed that observed lignin degradation and modification increase the bioavailability of the carbohydrates in the wheat based compost.
To our knowledge, this is the first time that degradation and metabolization of lignin by A. mycelium was shown directly on the lignin structure in mycelium grown wheat straw based compost. Overall, our research provides more insights in how A. bisporus mycelium degraded lignocellulosic biomass for mushroom growth, and in general, give new insights in lignocellulosic plant biomass degradation.
Conclusion
During PI of composting, no changes in carbohydrates and lignin were observed in the compost. In PII, 50% of carbohydrates, both cellulose and xylan were metabolized, while lignin structure was not. During 16 days of mycelium growth (PIII–16) 45% of lignin was metabolized and the remaining lignin was modified resulting in an increased S:G ratio (0.51 to 0.68). Furthermore, from both S and G phenylpropanoid units the decorations, mainly vinyl-groups, were removed from the phenolic skeleton.
Supporting Information
S1 Table. Identities of lignin-derived phenolic F/P and unknown compounds identified with Py-GC/MS with relative molar area higher than 1% in wheat straw (out of total F/P and unknown compounds molar area)
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0138909.s001
(DOCX)
S2 Table. Identities of lignin-derived phenolic S, G, F/P and unknown compounds below 1% of relative molar area in wheat straw (for S and G out of total S+G molar area, and for F/P and unknown out of total F/P + unknown molar area) identified with Py-GC/MS.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0138909.s002
(DOCX)
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: EJ WA MK HG. Performed the experiments: EJ. Analyzed the data: EJ AP. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: EJ AP WA MK HG. Wrote the paper: EJ AP WA MK HG.
References
- 1. Iiyama K, Stone BA, Macauley BJ. Compositional changes in compost during composting and growth of Agaricus bisporus. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1994;60: 1538–1546. pmid:16349255
- 2. Jurak E, Kabel MA, Gruppen H. Carbohydrate composition of compost during composting and mycelium growth of Agaricus bisporus. Carbohydr Polym. 2014;101: 281–288. pmid:24299775
- 3. Scalbert A, Monties B, Lallemand J-Y, Guittet E, Rolando C. Ether linkage between phenolic acids and lignin fractions from wheat straw. Phytochem. 1985;24: 1359–1362.
- 4. del Río JC, Rencoret J, Prinsen P, Martínez ÁT, Ralph J, Gutiérrez A. structural characterization of wheat straw lignin as revealed by analytical pyrolysis, 2D-NMR, and reductive cleavage methods. J Agric Food Chem. 2012;60: 5922–5935. pmid:22607527
- 5. Ralph J. Hydroxycinnamates in lignification. Phytochem Rev. 2010;9: 65–83.
- 6.
Gerrits JPG. Nutrition and compost. In: van Griensven LJLD, editor. The cultivation of mushrooms. Darlington mushroom laboratories. Rustington, UK. 1988. pp. 29–72.
- 7. Fermor TR, Wood DA. Degradation of bacteria by Agaricus bisporus and other fungi. J Gen Microbiol. 1981;126: 377–387.
- 8. Savoie J-M. Changes in enzyme activities during early growth of the edible mushroom, Agaricus bisporus, in compost. Mycol Res. 1998;102: 1113–1118.
- 9. Gerrits JPG, Bels-Koning HC, Muller FM. Changes in compost constituents during composting, pasteurisation and cropping. Mushroom Sci. 1967;6: 225–243.
- 10. Bonnen AM, Anton LH, Orth AB. Lignin-degrading enzymes of the commercial button mushroom, Agaricus bisporus. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1994;60: 960–965. pmid:16349223
- 11. Durrant A, Wood D, Cain R. Lignocellulose biodegradation by Agaricus bisporus during solid substrate fermentation. J Gen Appl Microbiol. 1991;137: 751–755.
- 12.
Jones D. Factors for converting percentages of nitrogen in foods and feeds into percentages of proteins: Washington, US Agric Circ. 1931;183: 1–16.
- 13. del Río JC, Gutiérrez A, Rodríguez IM, Ibarra D, Martínez ÁT. Composition of non-woody plant lignins and cinnamic acids by Py-GC/MS, Py/TMAH and FT-IR. J Anal Appl Pyrolysis. 2007;79: 39–46.
- 14. Ralph J, Hatfield RD. Pyrolysis-GC-MS characterization of forage materials. J Agric Food Chem. 1991;39: 1426.
- 15. Bisaria R, Vasudevan P, Bisaria V. Utilization of spent agro-residues from mushroom cultivation for biogas production. Appl Environ Microbiol Biotechnol. 1990;33: 607–609.
- 16. Kurtzman R, Zadrazil F. Physiological and taxonomic considerations for cultivation of Pleurotus mushrooms. Tropical Mushrooms: Biological Nature and Cultivation Methods Chinese University Press. 1982: 299–348.
- 17. Akinyle B, Akinyosoye F. Effect of Volvariella volvacea cultivation on the chemical composition of agrowastes. Afr J Biotechnol. 2011;4: 979–983.
- 18. Sales-Campos C, Araujo LM, Minhoni M, Andrade M. Análise físico-química e composição nutricional da matéria prima e de substratos pré e pós cultivo de Pleurotus ostreatus. Interc. 2010;35: 70–76.
- 19. Hammond J, Nichols R. Carbohydrate metabolism in Agaricus bisporus (Lange) Sing: changes in soluble carbohydrates during growth of mycelium and sporophore. J Gen Microbiol. 1976;93: 309–320. pmid:945325
- 20. Chen Y, Chefetz B, Rosario R, van Heemst JDH, Romaine CP, Hatcher PG. Chemical nature and composition of compost during mushroom growth. Compost Sci Util. 2000;8: 347–359.
- 21. Pan GX, Bolton JL, Leary GJ. Determination of ferulic and p-coumaric acids in wheat straw and the amounts released by mild acid and alkaline peroxide treatment. J Agric Food Chem. 1998;46: 5283–5288.
- 22. Wood D, Leatham G. Lignocellulose degradation during the life cycle of Agaricus bisporus. FEMS Microbiol Lett. 1983;20: 421–424.
- 23. Hildén K, Mäkelä MR, Lankinen P, Lundell T. Agaricus bisporus and related Agaricus species on lignocellulose: production of manganese peroxidase and multicopper oxidases. Fungal Genet Biol. 2013;55: 32–41. pmid:23454218
- 24. Morin E, Kohler A, Baker AR, Foulongne-Oriol M, Lombard V, Nagye LG, et al. Genome sequence of the button mushroom Agaricus bisporus reveals mechanisms governing adaptation to a humic-rich ecological niche. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2012;109: 17501–17506. pmid:23045686
- 25. Kerrigan RW, Challen MP, Burton KS. Agaricus bisporus genome sequence: A commentary. Fungal Genetics and Biology. 2013;55(0): 2–5.
- 26.
Patyshakuliyeva A, Post H, Zhou M, Jurak E, Heck AJR., Hildén KS, et al.(2015). Uncovering the abilities of Agaricus bisporus to degrade plant biomass throughout its life cycle. 2015. Published Online in Environ Microbiol. https://doi.org/10.1111/1462-2920.12967